General Discussions  
This is the place to discuss general issues related to the U-boat war or the war at sea in WWII. 
Re: Fate of SURCOUF
Posted by: Edward Michaud ()
Date: February 23, 2011 03:07PM

Gentlemen;
Please be advised that I am repying here to Mr. Lowrey's claim of my so-called "dubius" backround. I was never a US Navy SEAL but have on occaisions worked with "team members" both in and out of the Navy and during my commercial diving career. I was never court martialed in any way...but I did recieve several Captain's Masts during my assignement on the USS Richard E. Byrd, (DDG-23), for several violations of direct officer orders. Not exactly the devil Mr. Lowrey would make everyone believe, and as my honorable discharge would indicate I might add. My defense in this would be that I was youg and foolish...as most of us were at one time.
Over the years I have attempted repeatedly to have the webmasters of that dubius site to stop defaming me in such ways, with no results. It appears they merely repeat gossip by those who may have had a gripe with this or that person.

Referring to the Type XI off Cape Cod I can assure you that it is not only real but still there. The sonar imagry that I have shared with some that are commenting on this forum is indeed the real thing as well. With absolutely no alterations whatsoever. The one thing that would be difficult to change would be sonar readings, as such alterations would be clearly evident due to the grain in the image being altered with such changes. The subject wreck does have a stern mounted twin barreled covered gun mount, with no mount on the fore deck, but with remnents of the mount in circular form, indicating that said mount has come off of the wreck either through sinking or through being dragged off with stern-trawler netting. The fore hatch for the plane storage is well noted as well, which negates the possibility of a french vessel but classicaly of the German airplane installation found on the Type XI class.
The injuction was in relation to the US Navy's use of sub-contracted vessels activity on the site, and I brought this to the attention of the Pentagon and Naval forces in the field at the time, which included the use of the LA attack sub USS Hartford in attaining passive sonar readings of the site and intended follow-up by Naval divers via the sub-contracted vessels. At the time we were involved in rather delicate talks with both American and German offices in attempts to find amicable procedures for the project. The US State Department in their various macinations effectively forced us into financial desperation, which forced a temporary halt to operations. The area is a difficult one with 6 plus knots currents on average, and most of the time a complete sand burial of the subject wreck. The story is not over though, and once I again gain the opportunity to follow up on this project I will do so.
I would like to say additionaly, that I appreciate all of the forum thinking on all of this and there are quite a few points to consider mentioned by all the forum contributors...a great deal of material to think about and consider.

As an additinoal matter, at one time I had involved a company Sub Sea Recovery, (aka Sub Sea Research), to help in logistics support in my endeavors. I no longer am involved in SSR, but am involved in several other research endeavors not related to WWII losses, and as such am kept quite busy these days. The story of the Cape Cod U-Boat is of course, not yet ended.
Best;
Ed Michaud

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Written By Posted
projectCA35 jeroen 09/09/2002 09:51AM
Re: projectCA35 Michael Lowrey 09/09/2002 10:45AM
Re: projectCA35 Rainer Bruns 09/09/2002 02:21PM
Re: projectCA35 Helmut Lepper 09/10/2002 02:50PM
Re: projectCA35 jcrt 03/04/2011 01:01PM
Re: projectCA35 F. Morin 09/09/2002 04:23PM
Re: projectCA35 Rainer Bruns 09/09/2002 05:18PM
Re: projectCA35 Frank Blazich, Jr. 09/09/2002 08:48PM
Re: projectCA35 F. Morin 09/10/2002 04:04PM
Re: projectCA35 Rainer Bruns 09/10/2002 07:12PM
Re: projectCA35 Brian 09/10/2002 09:37PM
Re: projectCA35 Rainer Bruns 09/10/2002 11:17PM
Re: projectCA35 John Griffiths 09/11/2002 04:35PM
Re:French boat? Steve Cooper 09/11/2002 04:46PM
Re:French boat? Rainer Bruns 09/11/2002 05:07PM
Re:French boat? ludovic 09/12/2002 06:27AM
Re:French boat? Joe Brennan 09/12/2002 07:41AM
Re:French boat? ludovic 09/12/2002 09:08AM
Re:French boat? Rainer Bruns 09/12/2002 12:38PM
Re:French boat? Steve Cooper 09/12/2002 04:49PM
Re:French boat? Rainer Bruns 09/12/2002 06:20PM
Re:French boat? Joe Brennan 09/13/2002 04:27AM
Re:French boat? Steve Cooper 09/14/2002 04:41AM
Re:French boat? J.T. McDaniel 09/14/2002 10:42AM
Re:French boat? Steve Cooper 09/14/2002 03:06PM
Re: Surcouf & Project CA.35, Part.1 Terry Andrews 09/14/2002 05:45PM
Re: Surcouf & Project CA.35, Part.2 Terry Andrews 09/14/2002 07:17PM
Re: Surcouf & Project CA.35, Part.2 John Griffiths 09/14/2002 07:25PM
Re: Surcouf & Project CA.35, Part.2 J.T. McDaniel 09/14/2002 11:56PM
Re: Surcouf & Project CA.35, Part.2 John Griffiths 09/15/2002 09:03AM
Re: Surcouf & Project CA.35, Part.2 Steve Cooper 09/14/2002 09:41PM
Re: Surcouf & Project CA.35, Part.2 Vin 09/15/2002 08:42AM
Re: Surcouf & Project CA.35, Part.3 Terry Andrews 09/15/2002 09:07AM
Re: Surcouf fate? Joe Brennan 09/15/2002 10:42AM
Re: Surcouf's Fatal Last Journey. Part .4 Terry Andrews 09/15/2002 01:40PM
Re: Surcouf's Fatal Last Journey. Part .4 John Griffiths 09/15/2002 05:13PM
Re: Thompson Lykes Steve Cooper 09/15/2002 09:58PM
Re: Thompson Lykes John Griffiths 09/16/2002 07:26AM
Re: projectCA35 F. Morin 09/11/2002 09:35PM
Re: projectCA35 Rainer Bruns 09/11/2002 11:02PM
Re: projectCA35 F. Morin 09/12/2002 02:49PM
Re: projectCA35 F. Morin 09/14/2002 04:30PM
Re: projectCA35 Richard Watts 01/03/2015 02:42PM
Re: projectCA35 Michael Lowrey 09/15/2002 04:03PM
Re: Fate of SURCOUF F.H.Hallett 02/09/2011 06:18AM
Re: Fate of SURCOUF jcrt 02/09/2011 11:48AM
Re: Fate of SURCOUF Edward Michaud 02/23/2011 03:07PM
Re: Fate of SURCOUF Ron Booth,USN,Ret 04/16/2013 10:26PM
Re: Fate of SURCOUF Stan Norcom 02/23/2011 07:08PM


Your Name: 
Your Email: 
Subject: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
 ********  **     **  **     **  **     **  **     ** 
    **     **     **   **   **   **     **   **   **  
    **     **     **    ** **    **     **    ** **   
    **     **     **     ***     *********     ***    
    **      **   **     ** **    **     **    ** **   
    **       ** **     **   **   **     **   **   **  
    **        ***     **     **  **     **  **     **