WWI forum
World War One discussions.
U-Boat Confusion - Re: RMS Carmania and RMS Caronia
Posted by:
ph0ebus
()
Date: January 20, 2009 07:18PM
Hi all,
I am trying to pin down where the RMS Carmania and RMS Caronia were in February 1917. My understanding is that the RMS Carmania was at that time operating as a troopship at Gallipoli; where was RMS Caronia?
Also, would it have been likely that u-boat commanders would have known where these two ships were, generally speaking? I ask because the ship I am researching was misidentified as either of the above ships by the Kplt. (Petz - of U.85) who sank her, and given the RMS Carmania was operating elsewhere (and was twice the size, and painted in a different color scheme) I am a bit confused how he could have made such an error. Were such misidentifications common?
Thanks,
-Daniel
I am trying to pin down where the RMS Carmania and RMS Caronia were in February 1917. My understanding is that the RMS Carmania was at that time operating as a troopship at Gallipoli; where was RMS Caronia?
Also, would it have been likely that u-boat commanders would have known where these two ships were, generally speaking? I ask because the ship I am researching was misidentified as either of the above ships by the Kplt. (Petz - of U.85) who sank her, and given the RMS Carmania was operating elsewhere (and was twice the size, and painted in a different color scheme) I am a bit confused how he could have made such an error. Were such misidentifications common?
Thanks,
-Daniel
Subject | Written By | Posted |
---|---|---|
U-Boat Confusion - Re: RMS Carmania and RMS Caronia | ph0ebus | 01/20/2009 07:18PM |
Re: U-Boat Confusion - Re: RMS Carmania and RMS Caronia | Michael Lowrey | 01/21/2009 02:13AM |
Re: U-Boat Confusion - Re: RMS Carmania and RMS Caronia | ph0ebus | 01/22/2009 05:31PM |
Re: U-Boat Confusion - Re: RMS Carmania and RMS Caronia | reginald rostock | 10/08/2010 08:32PM |