Hi Rainer, thankyou for that, however I am now confused, what I have on U 124 at this time was she was attacked by A/C of VP-53 29/12 and looked for by HMS Godetia from TM1 which prevented her from attacking the 2 stragglers from TM1. U 124 then attacked TB1. Is this still correct ? and was after FFT4 incident ? Best regards John.