Fighting the U-boats

Allied Navies

A/S Trawlers


The A/S Trawler HMCS Liscomb.

The naval trawler is a concept for expeditiously converting a nation's fishing boats and fishermen to military assets. England used trawlers to maintain control of seaward approaches to major harbors. No one knew these waters as well as local fishermen, and the trawler was the ship type these fishermen understood and could operate effectively without further instruction. The Royal Navy maintained a small inventory of trawlers in peacetime, but requisitioned much larger numbers of civilian trawlers in wartime. The larger and newer trawlers and whalers were converted for antisubmarine use and the older and smaller trawlers were converted to minesweepers.

In September 1939, while 140 newly requisitioned trawlers were fitting out for antisubmarine service, the Royal Navy established the 1st A/S group of 5 trawlers at Portsmouth, the 2nd A/S group of 3 trawlers in the Western Approaches, the 3rd A/S group of 3 trawlers at Rosyth, and the 4th A/S group of 5 trawlers in the Mediterranean.

Armament

A single deck gun was mounted on each trawler. Antisubmarine trawlers were usually given a 4" gun approximately equal to the deck guns of the submarines they might encounter. Minesweeping trawlers usually received a 12 pounder, although vintage 3 pounders or 6 pounders were sometimes fitted temporarily until more suitable weapons became available. Trawlers were also given between two and four .303 calibre Lewis guns which were later augmented with a similar number of 20mm machineguns. In a surface battle with a U-boat, the trawler attempted to dissuade the U-boat deck gun crew with machineguns, while the U-boat might similarly aim its 20mm at the trawler's unshielded deck gun.

Antisubmarine trawlers were fitted with ASDIC and a few depth charge racks. Antisubmarine trawlers were typically assigned to five-ship groups. Small trawlers were difficult torpedo targets; and, while a U-boat might best a single trawler in a gunnery contest, it would be unable to withstand the combined attention of several trawlers. Antisubmarine trawlers could establish and maintain defensive perimeters around convoy assembly areas within which individual cargo ships could gain their formation stations for ocean steaming.

By May 1940 antisubmarine trawler strength had increased to 9 at Portsmouth, 23 in the Western Approaches, 65 at Rosyth, 19 at The Nore, 12 at Dover, and 25 in the Orkney & Shetlands. The Mediterranean force had increased to 12 and new groups of five were stationed at Gibraltar and in the South Atlantic. Another 20 trawlers were fitting out for antisubmarine service.

Trawlers are eminently seaworthy; so, when convoy escorts were needed after the fall of France, antisubmarine trawlers were pressed into escort service for which they were poorly suited. With maximum speeds of 10 to 12 knots, trawlers were able to maintain screening stations, but unable to maneuver effectively. If a trawler left station to investigate a contact or rescue the crew of a torpedoed ship, hours might pass before the trawler could regain station on the moving convoy. Escorting trawlers might discourage a timid U-boat acting independently, but an aggressive U-boat captain could use the superior surface speed of the U-boat to outmaneuver trawlers.

Successful wolf pack attacks of 1940 -- like the battle of HX-79 -- occured because slow escorts could be distracted to one side of the convoy giving time for a U-boat to approach and attack from another direction.

The Royal Navy classified requisitioned trawlers by manufacturer, although such classes were more diverse than traditional naval classifications:

The trawler BASSET, built in 1935, became the prototype for nearly 250 military trawlers built in the following ten years:

Many of the above listed trawlers were employed for minesweeping rather than antisubmarine work. Antisubmarine trawler distribution in May 1944 included 28 at Portsmouth, 33 in the Western Approaches, 10 at Rosyth, 7 at The Nore, 28 at Plymouth, and 36 in the Orkney & Shetlands. There were 10 trawlers at Gibraltar, 17 in the central Mediterranean, and 13 in the eastern Mediterranean. The South Atlantic force had increased to 22; and there were 12 in Iceland, 8 in the Azores, 13 in West Africa, 19 in South Africa, and 15 in the Indian Ocean.

U-boats sunk by trawlers (at least partial credit):
    U-111, U-343, U-452, U-551, U-731, and U-732.

A/S Trawlers sunk by German U-boats (16)
    Alouette, Barbara Robertson, Bedfordshire (USN load),
    Birdlip, Bredon, Ellesmere, Eoor Wyke, Ganilly, Hatburn Wyke,
    Kingston Sapphire, Laertes, Lady Shirley, Notts County, Orfasy,
    Rosemonde and Tervani.



In Some Foreign Field

Naisawald, L. VanLoan


Buy this title at


amazon.com
See more sellers

Books dealing with this subject include

Atlantic Jeopardy. Lund, Paul, 1992.
Atlantic Odyssey. Thwaites, Michael, 1999.
Los bacaladeros de PYSBE en la Guerra Civil Española. Mortera Perez, Artemio, 2002.
British and Dominion Warships of World War II. Lenton, H.T.and Colledge, J.J., 1968.
Gorzki los ORP Jastrzab. Damski, Zbigniew, 1987.
Ice Brothers. Wilson, Sloan, 1979. (transl.)
In Some Foreign Field. Naisawald, L. VanLoan, 1997.
Okret podwodny Jastrzab. Pertek, Jerzy, 1958.
Really Not Required. Warwick, Colin, 1997.
Sommergibili in guerra. N/A, 1956.
Under the Red Duster. Lewis, William J., 2003.
Þrautgóðir á raunastund, vol 3. Lúðvíksson, Steinar J., 1971.


Allied Navies