Re: A Question About Contests and Accuracy
Posted by: Grant Goodale ()
Date: July 06, 2003 09:49PM

Einsamer -

While I agree 100% with the comments made by Wiljan below, when you are entering a contest, spotting errors lies with the judges. If they do not know the subject matter, the errors will not be noticed.

Something to bear in mind is that a very few judges will probably dealing with ALL ships and their knowledge can not be very deep in all areas. Contrast that with a judge who is looking at 1/48 Axis single engine prop-driven monoplanes.

One also has to ask which is the greater sin - giving an award to a well done U-boat with a red hull or spotting the error and giving the award instead to a poorly done but correctly painted Yamato?

I'm glad that I am not judging :-)

FWIW

- Grant



Subject Written By Posted
A Question About Contests and Accuracy Einsamer Wolf 07/06/2003 01:25PM
Re: A Question About Contests and Accuracy Wiljan Bakers 07/06/2003 08:21PM
Re: A Question About Contests and Accuracy Grant Goodale 07/06/2003 09:49PM
Re: A Question About Contests and Accuracy Einsamer Wolf 07/07/2003 01:01AM
Re: A Question About Contests and Accuracy Grant Goodale 07/07/2003 09:16PM
Re: A Question About Contests and Accuracy Einsamer Wolf 07/08/2003 05:51AM