Movies and Films  
This is the forum for Movie and Film discussions. Again, our topic is naval warfare in WWII for the most part. 
Re: 'Ghostboat'
Posted by: Ken Dunn ()
Date: July 28, 2006 01:16PM

Hi Chris,

I just wanted to make sure someone coming along later wouldn’t mistake the movie U-571 for one that was historically accurate in any way.

U-570 was captured by the Brits and taken home during the war and U-505 was captured and brought home by the Americans during the war and the Brits also captured U-110 but it sunk before they could get it home. There were other U-boats that were boarded for a short time before they sank too. That’s about the extent of the U-571 story’s accuracy (a U-boat was captured) though. None of the captures happened anywhere close to the way the capture in the movie was depicted and the entire plot of the U-571 movie was fiction.

Its one thing to capture an enemy submarine and sail it or tow it home on the surface but it is entirely something else to actually immediately operate the captured sub on a mission. All WWII subs had some fundamental things in common but the devil is in the details and one small mistake operating a submarine and everybody dies.

U-570 was studied by the Brits and eventually put into service by them but I don’t think U-505 was ever even dived after it was captured. The Germans also put a captured Brit sub (and some from other countries as well) into operation during the war too but only after taking the time to study them.

Regards,

Ken Dunn

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Written By Posted
'Ghostboat' David W 03/27/2006 03:12PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' J.T. McDaniel 03/28/2006 02:01AM
Re: 'Ghostboat' Barry Scully 03/28/2006 08:08PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' & David Jason Phil Johnson 04/10/2006 12:30PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' Wiljan Bakers 04/04/2006 10:32PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' David W 04/05/2006 11:24AM
Re: 'Ghostboat' Brian 04/10/2006 12:52PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' Ian Stapley 04/11/2006 04:33PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' John Griffiths 06/14/2006 09:44PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' Christopher Miles 07/27/2006 02:51PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' Ken Dunn 07/27/2006 07:20PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' Christopher Miles 07/28/2006 10:42AM
Re: 'Ghostboat' Ken Dunn 07/28/2006 01:16PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' Christopher Miles 07/28/2006 03:08PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' ROBERT M. 07/28/2006 11:37PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' Dan Odenweller 07/28/2006 01:34PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' BM 11/29/2006 06:56PM
Re: 'Ghostboat' Fozzie 12/17/2009 12:39AM
Re: 'Ghostboat' JTMcDaniel 01/09/2010 05:44AM
Re: 'Ghostboat' ROBERT M. 01/09/2010 08:45AM
Re: 'Ghostboat' JTMcDaniel 01/10/2010 07:22AM


Your Name: 
Your Email: 
Subject: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
  ******    ********        **  ********   **       
 **    **   **              **  **     **  **       
 **         **              **  **     **  **       
 **   ****  ******          **  **     **  **       
 **    **   **        **    **  **     **  **       
 **    **   **        **    **  **     **  **       
  ******    ********   ******   ********   ********