Technology and Operations  
This forum is for discussing technological & operational matters pertaining to U-boats. 
RE: The Falklands...
Posted by: David Plummer ()
Date: June 29, 2000 06:58PM

In response to the person who said that my statement that modern diesel subs were derived from Type XXI was invalid, I have this to say.

The subs I mentioned are far from modern, they are now all second line submarines first commssioned in the late fifties to early sixties. However, al;l have a cigar-shapoe hull form adopted from Typoe XXI, and those boats are second generation derivatives. based off of submarines which were directly copied from tyoe XXI. By this time, however, they had abandoned the figure-eight internal hull configuration.

About Argentina's Type 209s, and tehir lack of success, wouyld be willing to bet it was bad torpedoes. Type 209 has a good fire control suite, but that only does any good with modern torpedoes. I don't reckon the Argentines were using state-of-the-art, like the Mark 48 ADCAP, or Marconi's Tigerfish torpedo. Probably the best they could get their hands on were Mark 37s, an aging american torpedo. But I would bet they were using straight-runners, and probably old ones. If that's the case, tehy could have run cold, run the wrong course, not exploded, exploded prematurely, etc. That's just a guess, but I know that lots of those sort of countries fall short on the weapons end of their submarine forces..

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Written By Posted
Type VIIC's in 2000 Robert Eno 06/22/2000 01:04AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Rainer Bruns 06/22/2000 01:15AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 joe brandt 06/23/2000 02:27AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Joe 06/22/2000 08:46AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Robert Eno 06/22/2000 11:23PM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Joe 06/23/2000 05:11AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Robert Eno 06/24/2000 03:43AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Joe 06/24/2000 06:55AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Robert Eno 06/24/2000 09:18PM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Don Baker 06/22/2000 11:26PM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Robert Eno 06/23/2000 12:18AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Sergio Ferraro 06/23/2000 06:47AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 SuperKraut 07/01/2000 01:59PM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Andreas Hansen 02/27/2003 04:54PM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Davi Plummer 06/23/2000 01:39AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Garth Mobey 06/23/2000 05:39AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Garth Mobey 06/28/2000 05:22AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Mike Sung 06/24/2000 05:08AM
RE: The Falklands... David Plummer 06/29/2000 06:58PM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 SuperKraut 07/01/2000 02:03PM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 Wheete 06/24/2000 05:39AM
RE: Type VIIC's in 2000 SuperKraut 07/01/2000 02:04PM
The Falklands... The Mule 06/29/2000 01:57PM
RE: The Falklands... Rainer Bruns 06/29/2000 02:47PM
RE: The Falklands... The Mule 06/30/2000 01:21PM


Your Name: 
Your Email: 
Subject: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
  *******   ********   ********   ********   **    ** 
 **     **  **     **  **     **  **     **  **   **  
 **         **     **  **     **  **     **  **  **   
 ********   ********   **     **  **     **  *****    
 **     **  **         **     **  **     **  **  **   
 **     **  **         **     **  **     **  **   **  
  *******   **         ********   ********   **    **